 Leslie Carrara-RudolphAbby Cadabby | Abby Cadabby |
 Kevin ClashElmo (Elmo as the Red Rabbit) (voice) | Elmo (Elmo as the Red Rabbit) (voice) |
 Jerry NelsonCount Von Count as the Counter-pillar (voice) | Count Von Count as the Counter-pillar (voice) |
 Caroll SpinneyOscar the Grouch as the Grouch of Hearts (voice) | Oscar the Grouch as the Grouch of Hearts (voice) |
 Eric JacobsonGrover as the Mad Hatter / Bert as Tweedle Dee (voice) | Grover as the Mad Hatter / Bert as Tweedle Dee (voice) |
 Steve WhitmireErnie as Tweedle Dum (voice) | Ernie as Tweedle Dum (voice) |
 David RudmanCookie Monster as the Cheshire Cookie Cat (voice) | Cookie Monster as the Cheshire Cookie Cat (voice) |
 Fran BrillZoe as Mousey the Hatter Helper (voice) | Zoe as Mousey the Hatter Helper (voice) |
 Carmen OsbahrRosita as Little Rose (voice) | Rosita as Little Rose (voice) |
 Tyler BunchBottle (voice) | Bottle (voice) |
 Rickey BoydCookie (voice) | Cookie (voice) |
 Paul McGinnisAdditional Muppets (voice) | Additional Muppets (voice) |
 Pam ArcieroAdditional Muppet Performer (voice) | Additional Muppet Performer (voice) |
 John E. KennedyAdditional Muppet Performer (voice) | Additional Muppet Performer (voice) |
 Martin P. RobinsonAdditional Muppet Performer (voice) | Additional Muppet Performer (voice) |
| DDavid StephensAdditional Muppet Performer (voice) | Additional Muppet Performer (voice) |
