Elmo is trying to make a Top Ten Countdown list for the radio station, but everyone keeps trying to share their favorite song with him. Meanwhile, Telly can't decide on his favorite song -- is it "The Alphabet Song", "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star" or "Baa Baa Black Sheep"?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kevin ClashElmo (voice) | Elmo (voice) |
 Martin P. RobinsonTelly / Snuffy (voice) | Telly / Snuffy (voice) |
 Caroll SpinneyBig Bird (voice) | Big Bird (voice) |
 Fran BrillZoe / Prairie Dawn (voice) | Zoe / Prairie Dawn (voice) |
 Roscoe OrmanGordon | Gordon |
| IImani PattersonMiles | Miles |
 Jerry NelsonCount von Count / Jackman Wolf (voice) | Count von Count / Jackman Wolf (voice) |