After breaking the mysterious "One Wish Willow" to win his crush's heart, a hopeless romantic finds himself getting exactly what he asked for but soon discovers that some desires come at a dark, sinister price.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Michael JohnstonBear | Bear |
 Inde NavarretteNikki | Nikki |
 Cooper TomlinsonIan | Ian |
 Megan LawlessSarah | Sarah |
 Andy RichterCarter | Carter |
 Haley FitzgeraldViola | Viola |
 Darin ToonderHarry | Harry |
 Anthony PavoneReggie | Reggie |
 JusticeJoe | Joe |
 Anthony CasabiancaChris | Chris |
 Chloe BreenRuthie | Ruthie |
 Malcolm KelnerBartender | Bartender |
| CCharles Santa CruzBackground | Background |
| AAlex MaystrikBackground | Background |
| MMariana SilvaBackground | Background |
| KKyle BlumenthalBackground | Background |
| JJorge LuquinBackground | Background |
| JJose HerreraBackground | Background |
 Emilio FloresBackground | Background |
 Manny LiottaBackground | Background |
| MMai Chi NguyenBackground | Background |
| TTim RobinsonBackground | Background |
| EEvan BrownBackground | Background |
| MMaddi HulburtBackground | Background |
| JJacob StephensBackground | Background |
| SSkyler ZurnBackground | Background |
| DDanielle KrettBackground | Background |
 Dylan Michael SearleBackground | Background |
| MMatthew JacksonBackground | Background |
| IItzel Ximena GonzalezBackground | Background |