| IIva BradleySelf - Amy’s Mother | Self - Amy’s Mother |
| RRon BradleySelf - Amy’s Father | Self - Amy’s Father |
| BBrad BradleySelf - Amy’s Brother | Self - Amy’s Brother |
| EErin SheridanSelf - Special Agent FBI | Self - Special Agent FBI |
| EErin CullatherSelf - Amy’s Childhood Friend | Self - Amy’s Childhood Friend |
| SSarah LuckSelf - Amy’s Friend | Self - Amy’s Friend |
| DDavid CarmichaelSelf - Eyewitness | Self - Eyewitness |
| KKirk DetweilerSelf - Cruise Director | Self - Cruise Director |
| AAdtzere MentarSelf - Harbor Police Chief, Curaçao | Self - Harbor Police Chief, Curaçao |
| AAmica DouglasSelf - Alister Douglas’ Daughter | Self - Alister Douglas’ Daughter |
| JJulia TracySelf - Amy’s Friend | Self - Amy’s Friend |
| JJamie BarnettSelf - Cruise Safety Advocate | Self - Cruise Safety Advocate |
| KKate LovelaceSelf - Amy’s Ex-Girlfriend | Self - Amy’s Ex-Girlfriend |
| VVictor McCollumSelf - Special Agent FBI | Self - Special Agent FBI |
| CChris FenwickSelf - Passenger | Self - Passenger |
| JJudy MaurerSelf - Eyewitness | Self - Eyewitness |
| MMichael ClarkSelf - Special Agent in Charge, FBI | Self - Special Agent in Charge, FBI |
| BBrent HunterSelf - Guest Relations Manager | Self - Guest Relations Manager |
| HHenry VrutaalSelf - Curaçao Coast Guard | Self - Curaçao Coast Guard |
| MMollie McClureSelf - Amy’s Former Girlfriend | Self - Amy’s Former Girlfriend |
| SStephanie JuddSelf - Amy’s Friend | Self - Amy’s Friend |
| AAnthony WillisSelf - Online Investigator | Self - Online Investigator |
| BBill HefnerSelf - Eyewitness | Self - Eyewitness |
| WWayne BrietagSelf - Passenger | Self - Passenger |
| LLori ThompsonSelf - Passenger | Self - Passenger |
