When a cosmic event turns Emma's dog and cat into two perfect guys, Emma reconsiders her outlook on dating, hilariously works out her trust issues, and ultimately learns to love herself.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kate MicucciEmma | Emma |
 Justin ChatwinAjax / Diego | Ajax / Diego |
 Steve HoweySummit / Sam | Summit / Sam |
 Hana Mae LeeNina | Nina |
 Josh BrenerLuke | Luke |
 Illeana DouglasMonty | Monty |
 Sean AstinCarl | Carl |
 Mark StranoKyle | Kyle |
| JJohn TerrellHipster on Bike | Hipster on Bike |
| DDon ReedAllen | Allen |
 Scott CoffeyLeather Dude | Leather Dude |
 Jeremy KahnTodd | Todd |
 Kathy GarverJean | Jean |
| JJoshua LomeliDiego on TV | Diego on TV |
| SSamantha JacksonFemale Assistant | Female Assistant |
| DDiane AmosWaitress | Waitress |
 Andrew LaingDan the Orderly | Dan the Orderly |
| GGina BerettaLilly | Lilly |
| JJennifer RosenDenise | Denise |
| MMario HerreraKid at Restaurant | Kid at Restaurant |
| MMelissa QuineMisty | Misty |
| BBob SaenzFire Chief | Fire Chief |
| EErik BraaBig Guy | Big Guy |
| OOlivia ChavezBig Guy's Girlfriend | Big Guy's Girlfriend |
| AAsher TerraYoung SPCA Woman | Young SPCA Woman |
| ZZosha RuthModeling Agency Assistant | Modeling Agency Assistant |
| TTheo StefanekModel | Model |
| MMike MicucciTaco Truck Owner | Taco Truck Owner |
| LLynne MicucciTaco Truck Owner | Taco Truck Owner |
| MMary HohlmanMother in the Park | Mother in the Park |