Carly heads to a small town to lead a church choir at Christmastime, facing her first holiday season without her mother. While there, she connects with a man back in town after serving in the Army.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Shenae Grimes-BeechCarly | Carly |
 Chris CarmackMatthew Wheeler | Matthew Wheeler |
 Janet KidderSusan Shephard | Susan Shephard |
 Lauren JacksonJenny Shephard | Jenny Shephard |
| GGrace LeerRiley Wheeler | Riley Wheeler |
 Brian MarkinsonPastor John | Pastor John |
 Kathleen DuborgDiane Wheeler | Diane Wheeler |
 Katrina ReynoldsAlice | Alice |
 Jay BrazeauGeorge | George |
 Josh ZahariaTyler | Tyler |
 Madeleine KeldersMrs. Richards | Mrs. Richards |