The Fairy Council puts Timmy on trial after he makes his millionth wish.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tara StrongTimmy / Baby Poof / Computer Voice (voice) | Timmy / Baby Poof / Computer Voice (voice) |
 Susanne BlakesleeWanda / Mom (voice) | Wanda / Mom (voice) |
 Daran NorrisCosmo / Dad / Jorgen (voice) | Cosmo / Dad / Jorgen (voice) |
 Eric BauzaFoop / Cyclops / Fairy Bailiff (voice) | Foop / Cyclops / Fairy Bailiff (voice) |
 Carlos AlazraquiCrocker / Mrs. Crocker / Fairy Elder #3 / Gnome (voice) | Crocker / Mrs. Crocker / Fairy Elder #3 / Gnome (voice) |
 Jeff BennettFairy Elder #1 / Father Time / Big Willy (voice) | Fairy Elder #1 / Father Time / Big Willy (voice) |
 Grey DeLisleVicki (voice) | Vicki (voice) |
 Gary LeRoi GrayA.J. (voice) | A.J. (voice) |
 Jay LenoCrimson Chin (voice) | Crimson Chin (voice) |
 Jason MarsdenChester (voice) | Chester (voice) |
 Rob PaulsenMark Chang (voice) | Mark Chang (voice) |
 Kevin Michael RichardsonFairy Elder #2 / Dark Laser (voice) | Fairy Elder #2 / Dark Laser (voice) |
 Jim WardChet Ubetcha (voice) | Chet Ubetcha (voice) |