A group of Catholic school friends, after being caught drawing an obscene comic book, plan a heist that will outdo their previous prank and make them local legends.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kieran CulkinTim Sullivan | Tim Sullivan |
 Emile HirschFrancis Doyle | Francis Doyle |
 Jena MaloneMargie Flynn | Margie Flynn |
 Jake RichardsonWade Scalisi | Wade Scalisi |
 Jodie FosterSister Assumpta | Sister Assumpta |
 Vincent D'OnofrioFather Casey | Father Casey |
 Melissa McBrideMrs. Doyle | Mrs. Doyle |
 Michael HardingMr. Doyle | Mr. Doyle |
| TTyler LongJoey Anderson | Joey Anderson |
 Arthur BridgersDonny Flynn | Donny Flynn |
 Scott SimpsonNewsie | Newsie |
 Yvonne EricksonMrs. Sullivan | Mrs. Sullivan |
 Chandler McIntyreNaturalist | Naturalist |