A young stranger, Brat Farrar, shows up claiming to be the twin brother of a young Englishman, Peter Ashby, who is set to inherit a huge fortune. Farrar claim to have a right to half of the estate.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Donald O'ConnorSelf - Host | Self - Host |
 Farley GrangerPeter Ashby / Brat Farrar | Peter Ashby / Brat Farrar |
 Judith AndersonAunt Bee | Aunt Bee |
 Terry MooreEleanor | Eleanor |
 Vincent PriceAlex | Alex |
 Patty McCormackJane | Jane |
 John WilliamsSandal | Sandal |