Aging sidekick Lefty Brown has ridden with Eddie Johnson his entire life. But when a rustler kills Eddie, Lefty is forced from his partner’s shadow and must confront the ugly realities of frontier justice.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Bill PullmanLefty Brown | Lefty Brown |
 Peter FondaEdward Johnson | Edward Johnson |
 Kathy BakerLaura Johnson | Laura Johnson |
 Jim CaviezelJimmy Bierce | Jimmy Bierce |
 Tommy FlanaganTom Harrah | Tom Harrah |
 Diego JosefJeremiah | Jeremiah |
 Joseph Lee AndersonOak | Oak |
 Michael SpearsBiscuit | Biscuit |
| DDillinger SteeleDoc | Doc |
| BBrian HenningsenSampson | Sampson |
 Emily JonesRed Blake | Red Blake |
 Lexi AnastasiaTownsperson | Townsperson |
 Joe AndersonFrank | Frank |
| JJosiah BurdickCowboy / Townsperson | Cowboy / Townsperson |
| DDuel FarnesVirgil | Virgil |
| TTyson GerhardtIrish William | Irish William |
 Adam O'ByrneCrobley | Crobley |
 Lewis PullmanBilly Kitchen | Billy Kitchen |
| SStephen Alan SederNoah Debow | Noah Debow |
| TTravis W BruyerCowboy (uncredited) | Cowboy (uncredited) |
| SScott McCauleyTownsperson (uncredited) | Townsperson (uncredited) |
| KKarlee JaneTownsperson (uncredited) | Townsperson (uncredited) |
 Mathieu SzymkowiakJimmy Bierce | Jimmy Bierce |