After a death in the family, siblings Angelica and James Zacherly travel to the small town of East Willard on Christmas Eve to pay their respects. They stay at a homely bed and breakfast where they learn the legend of Black Peter, Santa Claus' vengeful brother. But when they find the lost journal of Jeffrey Butler, they discover the town has its own sordid history - one more rooted in reality.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jennifer RunyonCarol Brickmann | Carol Brickmann |
 Julia FarrellAngelica Zacherly | Angelica Zacherly |
 Luc BernierJames Zacherly | James Zacherly |
| JJennii CarolineHolly Brickmann | Holly Brickmann |
| BBreana MitchellRegina Andrews | Regina Andrews |
| PPete LipinsHumphrey Brickmann | Humphrey Brickmann |
| JJeanne KernDoris | Doris |
| RRich KernBlack Peter / Jeffrey Butler | Black Peter / Jeffrey Butler |
| MMike CrawfordDrunk Santa | Drunk Santa |
| JJarad AllenThe Shape | The Shape |
 Jeff Dylan GrahamMax Zacherly | Max Zacherly |
| CChad HaufschildBlack Peter (voice) | Black Peter (voice) |
| SSarah MoshmanSwitchboard Operator | Switchboard Operator |
| KKia BeasonCaroler | Caroler |
| RRikki WallaceCaroler | Caroler |
| DDorothy BooraemCaroler | Caroler |
| GGreg KubitschekCaroler | Caroler |
| SShawn RayCaroler | Caroler |
| VVijay OlanderCaroler | Caroler |
| JJohnny TranCaroler | Caroler |