Internet sensation and old family friend of Aurora Teagarden, Poppy Wilson, has returned to Lawrenceton to start her new embroidery business. But not everyone is happy with Poppy's success when she turns up dead. To find the killer, Roe must follow the unsettling truths that lead her—into the path of the killer.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Candace Cameron BureAurora Teagarden | Aurora Teagarden |
 Marilu HennerAida Teagarden | Aida Teagarden |
 Lexa DoigSally Allison | Sally Allison |
 Peter BensonArthur Smith | Arthur Smith |
 James RittingerJason Dell | Jason Dell |
 Britt IrvinCara Embler | Cara Embler |
 Jesse MossDustin Sykes | Dustin Sykes |
 Ellie HarvieLillian Tibbett | Lillian Tibbett |
 Jerry WassermanMarv Wilson | Marv Wilson |
 Dave ColletteBubba Rankart | Bubba Rankart |
 Julia BensonLizzy Allison | Lizzy Allison |
 April TelekNicole Wilson | Nicole Wilson |
 Jordana LargyPoppy Wilson | Poppy Wilson |
 Catherine Lough HaggquistMayor Terry Sternholz | Mayor Terry Sternholz |
 Brad HarderOfficer Heard | Officer Heard |
 Dean MarshallMacon Turner | Macon Turner |
 Darla FayMaisie | Maisie |
 Terry IngramP.I. Doug Lemmon | P.I. Doug Lemmon |
 Benjamin WilkinsonAttorney | Attorney |
 Shaine JonesGas Station Attendant | Gas Station Attendant |
 Devon AlexanderLarry | Larry |