In 1990s New York, an undercover police officer receives an assignment to lure and arrest gay men. However, he's surprised to discover a scintillating connection with one of his targets. As their secret connection deepens and internal pressure to deliver arrests intensifies, he finds himself torn between duty and desire.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tom BlythLucas | Lucas |
 Russell ToveyAndrew | Andrew |
 Amy ForsythEmily | Emily |
 Maria DizziaMarie | Marie |
 Christian CookeRon | Ron |
 Gabe FazioUncle Paul | Uncle Paul |
 John Bedford LloydLt. Sollars | Lt. Sollars |
 Sam Asa BrownsteinChristian | Christian |
 Darius FraserJeff | Jeff |
 Alessandra Ford BalazsJessie | Jessie |
| JJoseph EmmiGus | Gus |
| LLuke BurkeBen | Ben |
| MMarlene ManciniNonna | Nonna |
| HHenry StockwellMan in Bathroom #1 | Man in Bathroom #1 |
| BBen AndersonMan in Bathroom #2 | Man in Bathroom #2 |
| JJason NgoMan in Bathroom #3 | Man in Bathroom #3 |
| CCharli EmmiNot listed | Not listed |
| OOliver FedrizziNot listed | Not listed |
| EEmily FedrizziLucas's Cousin | Lucas's Cousin |
| CCarmen Emmi IIILucas's Cousin | Lucas's Cousin |
| JJoseph Emmi Jr.Toddler Lucas | Toddler Lucas |
| RRachael HaegertyLucas's Cousin | Lucas's Cousin |
| CChristine AlbrightAunt Trish | Aunt Trish |
| LLauren StantonJoanne | Joanne |
| BBabs RubensteinTheater Attendant | Theater Attendant |
| CColby CoteAndrew Double | Andrew Double |
| OOliver BradfordAndrew's Son | Andrew's Son |