 Daniel KaluuyaOJ Haywood | OJ Haywood |
 Keke PalmerEmerald Haywood | Emerald Haywood |
 Brandon PereaAngel Torres | Angel Torres |
 Michael WincottAntlers Holst | Antlers Holst |
 Steven YeunRicky 'Jupe' Park | Ricky 'Jupe' Park |
 Wrenn SchmidtAmber Park | Amber Park |
 Keith DavidOtis Haywood Sr. | Otis Haywood Sr. |
 Devon GrayeRyder Muybridge | Ryder Muybridge |
 Terry NotaryGordy | Gordy |
 Barbie FerreiraNessie | Nessie |
 Donna MillsBonnie Clayton | Bonnie Clayton |
 Osgood PerkinsFynn Bachman | Fynn Bachman |
 Eddie JemisonBuster | Buster |
 Jacob KimYoung Ricky 'Jupe' Park | Young Ricky 'Jupe' Park |
 Sophia CotoMary Jo Elliot | Mary Jo Elliot |
 Jennifer LafleurPhyllis Mayberry / Margaret Houston | Phyllis Mayberry / Margaret Houston |
 Andrew Patrick RalstonTom Bogan / Brett Houston | Tom Bogan / Brett Houston |
 Lincoln LambertKolton Park | Kolton Park |
 Pierce KangPhoenix Park | Phoenix Park |
 Roman GrossMax Park | Max Park |
 Alex Hyde-WhiteGrizz | Grizz |
| HHetty ChangHetty Chang | Hetty Chang |
 Liza TreygerCommercial Makeup Artist | Commercial Makeup Artist |
 Ryan W. GarciaSheriff Reyes | Sheriff Reyes |
| CCourtney ElizabethMrs. Dolan | Mrs. Dolan |
| CCaden J. LovgrenJupiter's Claim Horse Wrangler | Jupiter's Claim Horse Wrangler |
| MMalcolm Jae O'SheaJupiter's Claim Outlaw | Jupiter's Claim Outlaw |
 Evan ShafranStudio Security Guard (uncredited) | Studio Security Guard (uncredited) |
 Mark Casimir Dyniewicz Jr.Fry's Customer (uncredited) | Fry's Customer (uncredited) |
| HHaley BabulaMary Jo Elliot (adult) (uncredited) | Mary Jo Elliot (adult) (uncredited) |
