College student Deena visits home and is roped into babysitting. The local sheriff is mailed a piece of evidence and is led on a scavenger hunt to reveal the killer of another babysitter.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jessica ClementDeena | Deena |
 Ryan RobbinsSheriff Rodney Arnold | Sheriff Rodney Arnold |
 Summer H. HowellEmily Golding | Emily Golding |
 Keegan Connor TracyElizabeth Talbot | Elizabeth Talbot |
 Matty FinochioOfficer Butch Cassidy | Officer Butch Cassidy |
| MMax ChristensenMax Arnold | Max Arnold |
 Ben CockellChad | Chad |
 David FeehanThe Reaper | The Reaper |
 Bryn SamuelWillis Hanover | Willis Hanover |
 Savannah MillerHaddie | Haddie |
 Susan SerraoSheila | Sheila |
 Huxley FisherMark | Mark |
 Isla SpencerMarina | Marina |
 Sofie KaneDottie | Dottie |
 Deborah FergusonMrs. Dunham | Mrs. Dunham |
 Blair YoungDr. Hall | Dr. Hall |
 Jocelyn ChuggAbby | Abby |
 Lonni OlsonWalt | Walt |
| DDrake SeipertConnor Davis | Connor Davis |