 Dave GoelzGonzo / Bunsen / Zoot / Beauregard / Waldorf / Chip / Randy Pig | Gonzo / Bunsen / Zoot / Beauregard / Waldorf / Chip / Randy Pig |
 Bill BarrettaPepe / Rowlf / Dr. Teeth / The Swedish Chef | Pepe / Rowlf / Dr. Teeth / The Swedish Chef |
 Eric JacobsonMiss Piggy / Fozzie / Animal / Sam Eagle | Miss Piggy / Fozzie / Animal / Sam Eagle |
 Matt VogelKermit / Uncle Deadly / Floyd / Sweetums / Pops | Kermit / Uncle Deadly / Floyd / Sweetums / Pops |
 Peter LinzWalter / Joe From Legal / Statler / Robin / Lips | Walter / Joe From Legal / Statler / Robin / Lips |
 David RudmanScooter / Janice / Beaker / Wayne / Squid Ghost | Scooter / Janice / Beaker / Wayne / Squid Ghost |
 Alice DinneanMummy / Caretaker's Dog / Miss Cartier | Mummy / Caretaker's Dog / Miss Cartier |
 Bruce LanoilDuddy / Ballroom Rat | Duddy / Ballroom Rat |
 Julianne BuescherYolanda / Beverly Plume / Wanda / Screaming Ghost | Yolanda / Beverly Plume / Wanda / Screaming Ghost |
 Brian HensonSal Minella | Sal Minella |
 Sarah OhSupporting Muppet Performer | Supporting Muppet Performer |
| NNicolette SantinoParty Tomato | Party Tomato |
 Colleen SmithSupporting Muppet Performer | Supporting Muppet Performer |
| AAlan TrautmanSupporting Muppet Performer | Supporting Muppet Performer |
| AAlex VillaPumpkin | Pumpkin |
 Will ArnettThe Host | The Host |
 Yvette Nicole BrownThe Driver | The Driver |
 Darren CrissThe Caretaker | The Caretaker |
 Taraji P. HensonThe Bride | The Bride |
 Ed AsnerGhost of Claude | Ghost of Claude |
 Kim IrvineHaunted Mansion Maid | Haunted Mansion Maid |
 Skai JacksonSinging Bust | Singing Bust |
 Geoff KeighleySinging Bust | Singing Bust |
 Justina MachadoSinging Bust | Singing Bust |
 Jeannie MaiGhost of Maude | Ghost of Maude |
 Chrissy MetzGhost of Harriet | Ghost of Harriet |
 Alfonso RibeiroGhost of Fred | Ghost of Fred |
 Craig RobinsonSinging Bust | Singing Bust |
 Pat SajakSinging Bust | Singing Bust |
 John StamosFamous Person | Famous Person |
