Sleepy Hollow is the home of America’s original horror story: the tale of the headless horseman. But horror doesn’t just disappear. Now, filmmakers from the area have tackled the new legends of terror in this iconic area.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| MMarilyn OranMargaret | Margaret |
| ZZora Iman CrewsElizabeth | Elizabeth |
| EEric Jay SonnenscheinAlexander | Alexander |
 Amanda SonnenscheinGirl in Park | Girl in Park |
 Chloe DykstraMel | Mel |
| LLeo CamachoTom | Tom |
| SSkylar Grace HillIzzy | Izzy |
| GGeoff BurtThe Narrator | The Narrator |
| AAmy GeigerHost (V.O.) | Host (V.O.) |
| JJohn GeierAlbert Fish | Albert Fish |
| JJoseph David SuricoPeter Loring | Peter Loring |
| BBill McAndrewsPhilip Libretor | Philip Libretor |
| HHelen M GlassmanAnna Fish | Anna Fish |
| SSteven WishmanHarrold Aster | Harrold Aster |
| MMargaret G. RingwoodJudy Aster | Judy Aster |
| AAmanda DuranteTammy | Tammy |
| BBea MaverJessica | Jessica |
| MMatt SullivanMark | Mark |
| AAllan StyerDr. Weiss | Dr. Weiss |
| GGrannell KnoxGrannell | Grannell |
| HHadas KnoxHadas | Hadas |
| IIrene KnoxIrene | Irene |
| GGrannell Knox, Sr.Grannell, Sr. | Grannell, Sr. |
| GGeoffrey KnoxGeoffrey | Geoffrey |
| AAmanda KnoxAmanda | Amanda |
| MMarie KnoxMarie | Marie |
| KKathy KnoxKathy | Kathy |
| AAmos MarguliesAmos | Amos |
| WWilmary RodriguezWilmary | Wilmary |
| SSheila DvorakSheila | Sheila |