Seven college students are picked to travel to a private island owned by the reclusive Vincent King and his film-obsessed wife Mary Shelley to study island wildlife. But is isn't long when a mysterious killer begins killing the students one-by-one, and modeling them after gory murder scenes from numerous horror films.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Danica McKellarEmily Longley | Emily Longley |
 Jay Kenneth JohnsonJohnny | Johnny |
 William ForsytheWilly | Willy |
 Sean KananVincent King | Vincent King |
 Juliet LandauMary Shelley King | Mary Shelley King |
 Tony BurtonSheriff Stoker | Sheriff Stoker |
 Justin ChonRicky | Ricky |
 Travis SchuldtTim | Tim |
 Lochlyn MunroDeputy Radley | Deputy Radley |
| MMike WittlinMr. Argento | Mr. Argento |
 Adrienne FrantzMaddy Roth | Maddy Roth |
 Gabrielle RichensSylvia | Sylvia |
| WWon-G'Q' | 'Q' |
 Burt YoungJ.T. Bates | J.T. Bates |
 Kane HodderMr. Carpenter - First victim | Mr. Carpenter - First victim |
| RRichard ComeauVincent's Father (uncredited) | Vincent's Father (uncredited) |
 Tammy FeliceMaddy's Tough Girlfriend | Maddy's Tough Girlfriend |
 Jenna MorascaSamantha, Tim's girlfriend | Samantha, Tim's girlfriend |
 Suzie PollardHot Coed | Hot Coed |
| NNoah GuyTatooed Leg Pumper | Tatooed Leg Pumper |
| TTeague CowleyDismembered Hunter | Dismembered Hunter |
| CCody HartmanYoung Vincent | Young Vincent |
 Daryl J. JohnsonSweet D | Sweet D |
 Clifford ParksBrandon | Brandon |
| TTonia Marie RoséeSherrie | Sherrie |