A slice of life story that follows a large Italian family on Christmas Eve as they prepare for the traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes, reminisce about the past and seek love in the future.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Skyler GisondoTony | Tony |
 Madison IsemanBeth | Beth |
 Josh HelmanJuke | Juke |
 Addison TimlinKatie | Katie |
 Ray AbruzzoUncle Carmine | Uncle Carmine |
 Andrew SchulzAngelo | Angelo |
 Jess DarrowSarah | Sarah |
| CCameron RostamiVince | Vince |
 Jean ZarzourMarian Oliverio | Marian Oliverio |
 David KallawaySweeney | Sweeney |
 Lynn CohenNonnie | Nonnie |
 Joe PantolianoUncle Frankie | Uncle Frankie |
 Paul Ben-VictorJohnny | Johnny |
 Lisa Velten SmithMrs. Claremont | Mrs. Claremont |
| TTony BinghamTony Sr. | Tony Sr. |
 Allen WilliamsonPrentice | Prentice |
| AAaron J. SheltonStallings | Stallings |
| JJackson NunnWoody | Woody |
| PPorter StilesPorter | Porter |
| TTravis TeffnerDude | Dude |
| NNancy TelzerowMom | Mom |
 Tommy LafitteBernard | Bernard |