Two adopted brothers, Brandon and Cole, both meet a new girl and Brandon calls "Dibs" on her. Cole tries his best to stay out of the way but the girl winds up falling for him anyways.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| SSamual CharlesCole | Cole |
| BBrett MalineBrandon | Brandon |
 Zita VassLauren | Lauren |
 Anna Sophia BerglundKatie | Katie |
 Roshelle BaierJackie | Jackie |
 Caroline ClementsCaroline / Dater #4 | Caroline / Dater #4 |
 Brando EatonJack | Jack |
 Brad GageJake | Jake |
 Heidi GardnerErica | Erica |
 Arlan GodthaabBrandon & Cole's Dad | Brandon & Cole's Dad |
| JJulie O’ConnerAndi | Andi |
 Brittany SamsonJayd | Jayd |