| HHarry SmithNarrator (voice) | Narrator (voice) |
 James StewartGeorge Bailey (archive footage) | George Bailey (archive footage) |
 Donna ReedMary Bailey (archive footage) | Mary Bailey (archive footage) |
 Wayne AllwineMickey Mouse (archive footage) | Mickey Mouse (archive footage) |
 Peter BillingsleyRalphie Parker (archive footage) | Ralphie Parker (archive footage) |
 Robert ClarkeFred (archive footage) | Fred (archive footage) |
 Rosemary ClooneyBetty Haynes (archive footage) | Betty Haynes (archive footage) |
 Bing CrosbyBob Wallace (archive footage) | Bob Wallace (archive footage) |
 Melinda DillonMrs. Parker (archive footage) | Mrs. Parker (archive footage) |
 Taylor HolmesEbeneezer Scrooge (archive footage) | Ebeneezer Scrooge (archive footage) |
 Robert HyattTiny Tim (archive footage) | Tiny Tim (archive footage) |
 Todd KarnsHarry Bailey (archive footage) | Harry Bailey (archive footage) |
 Danny KayePhil Davis (archive footage) | Phil Davis (archive footage) |
 Darren McGavinMr. Parker (archive footage) | Mr. Parker (archive footage) |
 Vera-EllenJudy Haynes (archive footage) | Judy Haynes (archive footage) |
| PPatrick WhyteBob Cratchit (archive footage) | Bob Cratchit (archive footage) |
 Alan YoungScrooge McDuck (archive footage) | Scrooge McDuck (archive footage) |