In the year 1935, a teen named Billy Bathgate finds first love while becoming the protégé of fledgling gangster Dutch Schultz.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Loren DeanBilly Bathgate | Billy Bathgate |
 Dustin HoffmanDutch Schultz | Dutch Schultz |
 Nicole KidmanDrew Preston | Drew Preston |
 Bruce WillisBo Weinberg | Bo Weinberg |
 Steve BuscemiIrving | Irving |
 Stanley TucciLucky Luciano | Lucky Luciano |
 Steven HillOtto Berman | Otto Berman |
| BBilly JayeMickey | Mickey |
 John CostelloeLulu | Lulu |
 Timothy JeromeDixie Davis | Dixie Davis |
 Mike StarrJulie Martin | Julie Martin |
 Robert F. ColesberryJack Kelly | Jack Kelly |
 Stephen JoyceMr. Hines | Mr. Hines |
 Frances ConroyMary Behan | Mary Behan |
 Moira KellyBecky | Becky |
 Kevin CorriganArnold | Arnold |
| RRob KramerBilly's Gang | Billy's Gang |
 Xander BerkeleyHarvey Preston | Harvey Preston |
 Katharine HoughtonCharlotte | Charlotte |
 Jack MulcahyFire Inspector | Fire Inspector |
 Kenny VanceDutch's Thug | Dutch's Thug |
| TTeddy CleanthesSupervisor | Supervisor |
 Barry McGovernNot listed | Not listed |
 John MoraitisLucianno's Bodyguard | Lucianno's Bodyguard |