A murder investigation is reignited in a house that is considered haunted by the Lawrenceton locals and where years ago Aurora and Sally, as teenagers, discovered a body.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Candace Cameron BureAurora Teagarden | Aurora Teagarden |
 Niall MatterNick Miller | Nick Miller |
 Marilu HennerAida Teagarden | Aida Teagarden |
 Lexa DoigSally Allison | Sally Allison |
 Peter BensonArthur Smith | Arthur Smith |
 Miranda FrigonLynn Smith | Lynn Smith |
 Dylan SloanePhillip Pifer | Phillip Pifer |
 Ellie HarvieLillian Tibbett | Lillian Tibbett |
 Cole VigueDavis Mettle | Davis Mettle |
 Julia BensonLizzy Allison | Lizzy Allison |
 Natasha BureTeen Aurora | Teen Aurora |
 Mia ShanksTeen Sally | Teen Sally |
| OOwen GatesTeen Jack | Teen Jack |
| RRyan MutamaFrank Brunelli | Frank Brunelli |
 Zahf ParooTom Wilkie | Tom Wilkie |
 Graeme McCombZachary Blank | Zachary Blank |
 Ben CottonReggie Harris | Reggie Harris |
 Donny LucasAnthony Brunelli | Anthony Brunelli |
 Lynda BoydMona Dilger | Mona Dilger |
 Jodelle FerlandTamara Dilger | Tamara Dilger |
 Brad HarderSergeant Heard | Sergeant Heard |