 Betty HuttonAnnie Oakley | Annie Oakley |
 Howard KeelFrank Butler | Frank Butler |
 Louis CalhernCol. Buffalo Bill Cody | Col. Buffalo Bill Cody |
 J. Carrol NaishChief Sitting Bull | Chief Sitting Bull |
 Edward ArnoldPawnee Bill | Pawnee Bill |
 Keenan WynnCharlie Davenport | Charlie Davenport |
 Benay VenutaDolly Tate | Dolly Tate |
 Clinton SundbergFoster Wilson | Foster Wilson |
 Dorothy AbbottCarriage Woman (uncredited) | Carriage Woman (uncredited) |
| BBette ArlenCarriage Passenger (uncredited) | Carriage Passenger (uncredited) |
| PPolly BaileyMinor Role (uncredited) | Minor Role (uncredited) |
| HHal BellDancer (uncredited) | Dancer (uncredited) |
| EEvelyn BeresfordQueen Victoria (uncredited) | Queen Victoria (uncredited) |
| MMargaret BertBit Role (uncredited) | Bit Role (uncredited) |
| NNorman BorineDancer (uncredited) | Dancer (uncredited) |
| TTex BrodusBall Guest (uncredited) | Ball Guest (uncredited) |
| EEleanor BrownMinnie Oakley (uncredited) | Minnie Oakley (uncredited) |
| AArchie ButlerCowboy (uncredited) | Cowboy (uncredited) |
 George CalligaBall Guest (uncredited) | Ball Guest (uncredited) |
| SSue CarltonMinor Role (uncredited) | Minor Role (uncredited) |
| BBridget CarrCarriage Woman (uncredited) | Carriage Woman (uncredited) |
 Sue CaseyCowgirl (uncredited) | Cowgirl (uncredited) |
 André CharlotFrench President Emile Loubet (uncredited) | French President Emile Loubet (uncredited) |
 Dorinda CliftonCowgirl (uncredited) | Cowgirl (uncredited) |
 Mae ClarkeMrs. Adams (uncredited) | Mrs. Adams (uncredited) |
| DDiane DickNellie Oakley (uncredited) | Nellie Oakley (uncredited) |
| HHelen DicksonSour-Faced Wife (uncredited) | Sour-Faced Wife (uncredited) |
| MMichael DuganCowboy (uncredited) | Cowboy (uncredited) |
 Phil DunhamCynical Man (uncredited) | Cynical Man (uncredited) |
 Edward EarleFootman (uncredited) | Footman (uncredited) |
