This anthology gathers four episodes of the 1985-87 television series "Amazing Stories." Santa Claus (Douglas Seale) gets arrested when a burglar alarm goes off as he's delivering presents. A lonely bachelor (John Lithgow) buys a mysterious doll. A museum thief (Danny DeVito) gives a purloined ring to his wife (Rhea Perlman), unaware that the previous owner's ghost inhabits it, and 75 years after he accidentally caused a train to crash, an old man (Roberts Blossom) waits for his penance.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Danny DeVitoHerbert | Herbert |
 Rhea PerlmanLois | Lois |
 John LithgowJohn Walters | John Walters |
 Lukas HaasBrian Globe | Brian Globe |
 Douglas SealeSanta Claus | Santa Claus |
 Roberts BlossomOpa Globe | Opa Globe |
 Pat HingleSheriff | Sheriff |
 Gabriel DamonBobby Mynes | Bobby Mynes |
| MMarvin J. McIntyreDeputy Weatherby | Deputy Weatherby |
 Frances BayMrs. Santa Claus | Mrs. Santa Claus |
 Stephen LeeDad | Dad |
| JJoan WellesMom | Mom |
 Dick BalduzziDrunk Santa #1 | Drunk Santa #1 |
| GGerry GibsonDrunk Santa #2 | Drunk Santa #2 |
| WWilliam McDonaldDrunk Santa #3 | Drunk Santa #3 |
 Anne HelmMary Dickenson | Mary Dickenson |
 Sharon SpelmanSally | Sally |
 John Christopher JonesVin Colbeck | Vin Colbeck |
 Rain PhoenixDoris | Doris |
 Albert HagueMr. Liebemacher | Mr. Liebemacher |
 Louis GiambalvoHaggerty | Haggerty |
 Bernadette BirkettTina | Tina |
 David ByrdMr. Rhine | Mr. Rhine |
 Tracey WalterBlaze | Blaze |