Adam and Zooey have been trying to have a baby for several months, only to end up pregnant after a rape. Unsure of the parentage of their child, they decide to have the baby anyway.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| DDaria PuttaertZooey | Zooey |
| TTom KeenanAdam | Adam |
 Omar Alex KhanAndrew | Andrew |
| AAurum McBrideCarl at 5 | Carl at 5 |
| SSian GarrityCarl at 1 | Carl at 1 |
| MMetropolitan KinaschukCarl at 1 month | Carl at 1 month |