Brady Sutton returns from three years in prison and tries to go straight. One a member of the Butch Cassidy gang, he is still suspected of being cahoots with them. When Cassidy and his men rob the bank, he is blamed. Escaping from the townspeople, he once again joins up with Cassidy to wait for a chance to help bring him in.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Philip CareyBrady Sutton (as Phil Carey) | Brady Sutton (as Phil Carey) |
 Martha HyerNancy Warren | Nancy Warren |
 Douglas KennedyCharlie Veer | Charlie Veer |
 Gene EvansButch Cassidy / George Leroy Parker | Butch Cassidy / George Leroy Parker |
 William BishopSundance Kid | Sundance Kid |
 Aaron SpellingPetie Carver | Petie Carver |
 George KeymasGeorge Curry | George Curry |
 Roy RobertsSheriff McVey | Sheriff McVey |
 Harry HarveyMedford | Medford |
 Don BeddoeBanker Horace Warren | Banker Horace Warren |
 Mel Welles'Whiskey' Pearson | 'Whiskey' Pearson |
 Henry RowlandElza Lay | Elza Lay |
 John CasonO.C. Hanks | O.C. Hanks |
 Boyd StockmanTom McCarthy | Tom McCarthy |
 Guy Teague'Black Jack' Ketchum (as A. Guy Teague) | 'Black Jack' Ketchum (as A. Guy Teague) |
 Bob WoodwardMatt Garner | Matt Garner |
 Don C. HarveyBen Kilpatrck | Ben Kilpatrck |
| DDon CarlosBob Meeks | Bob Meeks |