Inspired by the book of the same name, film-maker James Marsh relays a tale of tragedy, murder and mayhem that erupted behind the respectable facade of Black River Falls, Wisconsin in the 19th century.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Ian HolmNarrator (voice) | Narrator (voice) |
| MMarcus MonroeYoung Anderson | Young Anderson |
| MMarilyn WhitePauline L'Allemand | Pauline L'Allemand |
| JJohn BaltesUndertaker | Undertaker |
| MMolly Nikki AndersonMrs. Larson | Mrs. Larson |
| BBrittany HaydockBaptized Girl | Baptized Girl |
| EEddie KunzAbandoned Boy | Abandoned Boy |
| SSteven StrobelUnion Man | Union Man |