During Christmas and Hanukkah, Rebecca and Hank must go through the anxiety-filled process of meeting the in-laws while immersed in their future family holiday traditions.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Cynthia StevensonMarilyn Kringle | Marilyn Kringle |
 Vikki KrinskyRebecca Fine | Rebecca Fine |
| TTommy LioutasHenry Kringle | Henry Kringle |
 Wendie MalickSuzie Fine | Suzie Fine |
 David EisnerMarvin Fine | Marvin Fine |
 Patrick McKennaHank Kringle | Hank Kringle |
 Reagan PasternakKristy Easterbrook | Kristy Easterbrook |
 Martin DoyleTom Schultz | Tom Schultz |
 Rahnuma PanthakyKay | Kay |
| KKate AshbyReporter | Reporter |
 Richard WaughReverend Bill | Reverend Bill |
 Astrid Van WierenMrs. Schultz | Mrs. Schultz |
 John Paul RuttanBoy (uncredited) | Boy (uncredited) |