Decades after covering up his classmate’s murder, Michael has moved on from his reservation and fractured past. When a man who shares his violent secret seeks vengeance, Michael goes to great lengths to protect his new life with his wife and boss from the demons of his past.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Michael GreyeyesMichael/Makwa | Michael/Makwa |
 Chaske SpencerTeddo | Teddo |
 Kate BosworthGreta | Greta |
 Phoenix WilsonYoung Makwa | Young Makwa |
| JJulian GopalYoung Teddo | Young Teddo |
 Lisa CromartyCammy | Cammy |
 Jesse EisenbergJerry | Jerry |
| EElisha PrattDarren | Darren |
 Scott HazeFather Daniels | Father Daniels |
| TTres GarciaDaniel | Daniel |
 Sheri FosterLisa Wolf | Lisa Wolf |
| MMarissa WoolfKimber | Kimber |
 Evan AssanteClassmate | Classmate |
| SSaxon Keanu NealSchoolmate | Schoolmate |
| CClaudia LeeRebecca | Rebecca |
 Jenna Leigh GreenIvy | Ivy |
 Bruce DavisFlorist | Florist |
| KKirstyn AndersonSelf - Background | Self - Background |
| MMattie WalkerExtra | Extra |
| AAndrew HooksPolice Officer (uncredited) | Police Officer (uncredited) |
 Garrett O'BrienFuneral Attendee (uncredited) | Funeral Attendee (uncredited) |
 Kody BurnsTeacher | Teacher |
 Tori HartleyNurse | Nurse |
 Lauren NewshamAlyse | Alyse |
 Justin ParksSecurity Officer | Security Officer |
 Stone GarciaNative Boy | Native Boy |
| JJoel MichaelyJonathan | Jonathan |
| KKaleo FranciscoFrancis | Francis |
| CColton KnausJames Wolf | James Wolf |
 Jennifer RaderYoung Lisa Wolf | Young Lisa Wolf |