 Payton LepinskiJonBenét Ramsey | JonBenét Ramsey |
 Eion BaileySteve Thomas | Steve Thomas |
 Michel GillJohn Ramsey | John Ramsey |
 Julia CampbellPatsy Ramsey | Patsy Ramsey |
 Brendon ZubOfficer French | Officer French |
 Vincent GaleADA Hofstrom | ADA Hofstrom |
 David KeeleyFleet White | Fleet White |
 Kendall CrossPriscilla White | Priscilla White |
 Camille SullivanDetective Linda Arndt | Detective Linda Arndt |
 Lane EdwardsDetective Ron Gosage | Detective Ron Gosage |
 Andrew MoxhamDetective Frank Quinn | Detective Frank Quinn |
 Hrothgar MathewsDetective Lou Smit | Detective Lou Smit |
 Kiefer O'ReillyBurke Ramsey | Burke Ramsey |
 Nels LennarsonCommander Eller | Commander Eller |
 Derek GreenJohn Fernie | John Fernie |
 Deborah FinkelBarbara Fernie | Barbara Fernie |
 Arran HennAndrea Kerry | Andrea Kerry |
 Anthony IngramRev. Hoverstock | Rev. Hoverstock |
 Matt KennedyJohn-Andrew Ramsey | John-Andrew Ramsey |
 Emma FlemingtonMelinda Ramsey | Melinda Ramsey |
 Primo AllonSergeant | Sergeant |
 Graeme DuffyFBI Voice Tech | FBI Voice Tech |
 Serge HoudeAttorney Byron Burroughs | Attorney Byron Burroughs |
 Marci T. House911 Operator | 911 Operator |
| PPhoebe LawrensonJonBenét Ramsey (voix) | JonBenét Ramsey (voix) |
 Curtis LumForgery Expert | Forgery Expert |
 London RobertsonDaphne White | Daphne White |
 Bronwen SmithVictim Advocate | Victim Advocate |
 Tom TasseGovernor Roy Romer | Governor Roy Romer |
 Ramon TerrellInterviewer | Interviewer |
