Mary recounts to her daughter Eva the childhood story of when Mary and her father fell through the ice on a frozen pond.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| EEva CrockerEva | Eva |
 Mary LewisAdult Mary/Adult Noreen | Adult Mary/Adult Noreen |
| BBonnie DeanYoung Mary | Young Mary |
| AAlicia Thoden RichardsonLeah | Leah |
| GGabriel WilliamsStephen | Stephen |
 James AllodiDad/Adult John | Dad/Adult John |
| JJulia MellinEight-year-old Noreen | Eight-year-old Noreen |
| SSara MeyerFive-year-old Aunt Sheila | Five-year-old Aunt Sheila |
| JJohn BairdGrandfather Paddy Murphy | Grandfather Paddy Murphy |
| BBrenda O'BrienAuntie Anne Murphy | Auntie Anne Murphy |
| PPaul PopeGrandfather P.J. Lewis | Grandfather P.J. Lewis |
| JJohn W. DoyleFamily Priest | Family Priest |
 Andy JonesNapoli Grace Keeper | Napoli Grace Keeper |
 Luke LawrencePatsy | Patsy |
 Allan HawcoYoung Paddy | Young Paddy |
| JJohn HousserGentleman Farmer: Young | Gentleman Farmer: Young |