 Damien EcholsSelf | Self |
 Jessie Misskelley Jr.Self | Self |
 Jason BaldwinSelf | Self |
| PPam HobbsSelf – Stevie Branch's Mother | Self – Stevie Branch's Mother |
| SSteve JonesSelf – Former Juvenile Officer, Crittenden County | Self – Former Juvenile Officer, Crittenden County |
| JJohn FoglemanSelf – Former Deputy Prosecutor | Self – Former Deputy Prosecutor |
| JJerry DriverSelf – Former Juvenile Corrections Officer | Self – Former Juvenile Corrections Officer |
| SSharon FrenchSelf – Juror #9 - Echols/Baldwin Trial | Self – Juror #9 - Echols/Baldwin Trial |
| LLorri DavisSelf – Damien's Wife | Self – Damien's Wife |
| MMara LeverittSelf – Author - "Devil's Knot" | Self – Author - "Devil's Knot" |
| MMartin HillSelf – Case Researcher | Self – Case Researcher |
| DDan StidhamSelf – Defense Attorney for Jessie Misskelley | Self – Defense Attorney for Jessie Misskelley |
| JJessie Misskelley Sr.Self – Jessie's Father | Self – Jessie's Father |
| SSteve DrizinSelf – Law Professor, Northwestern Univ. School of Law | Self – Law Professor, Northwestern Univ. School of Law |
| LLaura NiriderSelf – Staff Attorney, Center on Wrongful Convictions of Youth | Self – Staff Attorney, Center on Wrongful Convictions of Youth |
 Kiki DaireSelf – Childhood Friend of Damien & Jason (as Jennifer Bearden) | Self – Childhood Friend of Damien & Jason (as Jennifer Bearden) |
| DDavid BurnettSelf – Trial Judge | Self – Trial Judge |
| SStephanie DollarSelf – Defense Witness - Misskelley Trial | Self – Defense Witness - Misskelley Trial |
| DDennis CarterSelf – Defense Witness - Misskelley Trial | Self – Defense Witness - Misskelley Trial |
| DDennis RiordanSelf – Damien Echols' Attorney | Self – Damien Echols' Attorney |
 Eddie VedderSelf – WM3 Supporter | Self – WM3 Supporter |
 Henry RollinsSelf – WM3 Supporter | Self – WM3 Supporter |
 Peter JacksonSelf – WM3 Supporter | Self – WM3 Supporter |
| MMichael CarsonSelf – Former Juvenile Inmate | Self – Former Juvenile Inmate |
| JJoyce CuretonSelf – Director of Juvenile Detention, Retired | Self – Director of Juvenile Detention, Retired |
 John DouglasSelf – FBI Profiler, Retired | Self – FBI Profiler, Retired |
| JJohn Mark ByersSelf – Adoptive Father of Christopher Byers | Self – Adoptive Father of Christopher Byers |
| VVicki HutchesonSelf – Prosecution Witness | Self – Prosecution Witness |
| VVincent J.M. Di MaioSelf – Forensic Pathologist | Self – Forensic Pathologist |
| JJoseph GarnerSelf – Neighborhood Friend of the Byers Family | Self – Neighborhood Friend of the Byers Family |
