 Devin FranceWendy Darling | Wendy Darling |
| YYashua MackPeter Pan | Peter Pan |
 Gage NaquinDouglas Darling | Douglas Darling |
| GGavin NaquinJames Darling | James Darling |
| KKrzysztof MeynThomas Marshall | Thomas Marshall |
| AAhmad CageSweet Heavy | Sweet Heavy |
| RRomyri RossCudjoe Head | Cudjoe Head |
| KKevin PughJames Hook | James Hook |
 Lowell LandesBuzzo | Buzzo |
 Shay WalkerAngela Darling | Angela Darling |
| CCleopatra King WelchJane Darling | Jane Darling |
| PPamela HarperAunt Eloise | Aunt Eloise |
 Tommie Lynn MilazzoWendy Darling (Baby) | Wendy Darling (Baby) |
| CCatherine OttWendy Darling (Teenage) | Wendy Darling (Teenage) |
| AAlison CampbellWendy Darling (Adult) | Wendy Darling (Adult) |
| SStephanie Lynn WilsonWendy Darling (Adult) (voice) | Wendy Darling (Adult) (voice) |
| LLogan JonesDouglas Darling (Child) | Douglas Darling (Child) |
| JJohn BelloniDouglas Darling (Teenage) | Douglas Darling (Teenage) |
 Levy EasterlyDouglas Darling (Adult) | Douglas Darling (Adult) |
| LLuke JonesJames Darling (Child) | James Darling (Child) |
| WWeldon BarryThomas Marshall (Teenage) | Thomas Marshall (Teenage) |
| HHunter McGregorThomas Marshall (Adult) | Thomas Marshall (Adult) |
| JJaiden Lanji-BrownSweet Heavy (Teenage) | Sweet Heavy (Teenage) |
| IIrwin LewisSweet Heavy (Adult) | Sweet Heavy (Adult) |
| IIre SterlingCudjoe Head (Teenage) | Cudjoe Head (Teenage) |
| LLaura MagannCudjoe Head (Adult) | Cudjoe Head (Adult) |
| HHenry D. ColemanPonts | Ponts |
| JJesse GouedyElmo | Elmo |
| PPat GremillionPat | Pat |
| BBill GiroirGoose | Goose |
