Damien has been pen pals with his fifth grade teacher Mrs. Lewis for years, but as he enters college he starts to realize there's something fishy going on.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| AAlec Dean BoeschenDamien | Damien |
| CChristine CelozziLindsey | Lindsey |
| RRiver DowningYoung Damien | Young Damien |
| DDonnaKelli BarnettMrs. Lewis | Mrs. Lewis |
| CClaire GoldhushMarcy | Marcy |
| SShay AnuheaStacy | Stacy |
| NNicholas Brian KauffmanCraig | Craig |
| JJames ChewJosh | Josh |