Two opposing church members challenge each other to an absurd kickball game to recruit an outsider to their side of the pews.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Dawson EhlkeFrank Ames | Frank Ames |
| RRue NormanMichela Martin | Michela Martin |
| BBecca HartSkyler Anderson | Skyler Anderson |
| EElizabeth HawkinsonMarie Pangerl | Marie Pangerl |
| NNeal SkoyGary Hornsby | Gary Hornsby |
| BBenjamin DomaskDrake Adams | Drake Adams |
| AAnna StranzRuth Nelson | Ruth Nelson |
| JJoshua PetersonMichael Western | Michael Western |
| VVlad MessingTrevor Johnson | Trevor Johnson |
| JJake AnnisGarrett Hornsby | Garrett Hornsby |