Way Off Broadway is the story of five friends who, frustrated by the abrupt juxtaposition of being successful artists on the university level to poor struggling artists in New York City, take a crash course in life as they explore the dynamic of conflict in friendship involving sex, love, failure and betrayal.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Morena BaccarinRebecca | Rebecca |
 Brad BeyerDarrin | Darrin |
 Jordan GelberEthan | Ethan |
| MMichael ParducciMickey | Mickey |
 Forbes MarchJay | Jay |
| TTom SpackmanDirector | Director |
 Christopher MurneyMr. Kaufman | Mr. Kaufman |
 Neal JonesMr. Scott | Mr. Scott |
| JJulie LundChelsea | Chelsea |
 Jack FerverPhil | Phil |
 Larry PineKenneth Michaels | Kenneth Michaels |
 Chris PhillipsDirector's Assistant | Director's Assistant |
| BBrian TurnbaughMale Classmate | Male Classmate |
| EEugene Osborne SmithEddie | Eddie |
| OOlinda TurturroKim | Kim |
| SSuzanne LevinsonWaitress | Waitress |
| DDave NarbyKelly Decker | Kelly Decker |
| DDechen ThurmanGreggy | Greggy |
| KKaty HanszSamantha | Samantha |
| AAmanda BremenClaudia Lacey | Claudia Lacey |
 Bill DawesBen DePaul | Ben DePaul |
 Jarrod BunchChester | Chester |
| JJeffrey EmersonChris | Chris |
| JJack HowardAudition Guy | Audition Guy |
 Maggie LaceyTess | Tess |
| ZZoe HunterAuditioning Actress (Uncredited) | Auditioning Actress (Uncredited) |
| MMarcia LynnJulie (Uncredited) | Julie (Uncredited) |
 Cliff MoylanBartender (Uncredited) | Bartender (Uncredited) |
| AAndrew WeberDante (Uncredited) | Dante (Uncredited) |