The Indians and Yankees, both in a tight race with the White Sox, met at the Polo Grounds on August 16th, 1920. In the fifth inning, Carl Mays threw one of his "submarine" pitches that hit Ray Chapman in the head. Chapman collapsed at the plate. He was rushed to the hospital and died the next day, the only Major League Baseball player ever to be killed in a game. Grief tore through Cleveland and the pivotal moment led to an explosion on and off the field. The Indians, sparked by the addition of young shortstop Joe Sewell, recovered in time to win their first World Series Title. What resulted was a rivalry that would last 100 years.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| CChris LeabuRay Chapman (voice) | Ray Chapman (voice) |
| JJonah van BemmelenCarl Mays (voice) | Carl Mays (voice) |
| DDaniel SalmonsTris Speaker (voice) | Tris Speaker (voice) |
| MMegan BrautigamKathleen Daly (voice) | Kathleen Daly (voice) |
| JJim AbbottSelf | Self |
| SSandy Alomar Jr.Self | Self |
| MMarty AppelSelf | Self |
| MMandy BellSelf | Self |
 Sherrod BrownSelf | Self |
 Craig CartonSelf | Self |
| KKenny LoftonSelf | Self |
 Terry FranconaSelf | Self |
 Bob FellerSelf | Self |
| JJim LeyritzSelf | Self |
 Chris 'Mad Dog' RussoSelf | Self |
| AAndre ThorntonSelf | Self |
 Tom VerducciSelf | Self |
| LLesley VisserSelf | Self |