A little Christmas magic causes two coworkers with contrasting lifestyles to switch sexual orientations.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tom ArnoldJoe Bergers | Joe Bergers |
 Tom ArchdeaconSteve | Steve |
 Nathaniel MarstonTony | Tony |
 Mike StarrJohn | John |
 Dee WallaceMary | Mary |
 Kirsten LeaSarah | Sarah |
| RRick KaratasBrian | Brian |
 Emrhys CooperMichael | Michael |
 Lindsay HollisterLaura | Laura |
| DDarren Keefe ReiherDanny | Danny |
 Sammy SheikCarlos | Carlos |
 Jackie DebatinTrish | Trish |
| TTina LynchKathy | Kathy |
| CChandler LutzStefanie | Stefanie |
 Vincent De PaulKeith | Keith |
 Jennifer ChoeRachel | Rachel |
 Adriana FrickeMaria | Maria |
 Bruce VilanchBruce Vilanch | Bruce Vilanch |
 Bunny LevineSister Betty | Sister Betty |
 Jason StuartDr. Feist | Dr. Feist |
 Chane't JohnsonPsychic | Psychic |
| CChris DamianoEvangelist | Evangelist |
| LLorraine Marx EpsteinTherapist | Therapist |
 Bridgetta TomarchioGina | Gina |
| LLarry WeissmanHarold | Harold |
| EEric CasaccioGlen | Glen |
| JJabari JonesLeonard | Leonard |
| RRenzo LewisInfomercial Guy | Infomercial Guy |
| BBecca BattoeHot Girl | Hot Girl |
| AAdam BorichCute Guy on Street | Cute Guy on Street |