 Ben JohnsonTravis Blue | Travis Blue |
 Joanne DruDenver | Denver |
 Harry Carey Jr.Sandy | Sandy |
 Ward BondElder Wiggs | Elder Wiggs |
 Charles KemperUncle Shiloh Clegg | Uncle Shiloh Clegg |
 Alan MowbrayDr. A. Locksley Hall | Dr. A. Locksley Hall |
 Jane DarwellSister Ledyard | Sister Ledyard |
 Ruth CliffordFleuretty Phyffe | Fleuretty Phyffe |
 Russell SimpsonAdam Perkins | Adam Perkins |
| KKathleen O'MalleyPrudence Perkins | Prudence Perkins |
 James ArnessFloyd Clegg | Floyd Clegg |
 Francis FordMr. Peachtree | Mr. Peachtree |
 Fred LibbyReese Clegg | Reese Clegg |
 Jim ThorpeNavajo Indian | Navajo Indian |
 Mickey SimpsonJesse Clegg | Jesse Clegg |
 Cliff LyonsMarshal of Crystal City | Marshal of Crystal City |
| DDon SummersSam Jenkins | Sam Jenkins |
 MovitaYoung Navajo Indian | Young Navajo Indian |
 Hank WordenLuke Clegg | Luke Clegg |
 Chuck HaywardJackson (uncredited) | Jackson (uncredited) |
| DDanny BorzageAccordionist (uncredited) | Accordionist (uncredited) |
| LLee BradleyLeader of the Navajo Band (uncredited) | Leader of the Navajo Band (uncredited) |
 Nora BushSettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
| JJane CrowleySettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
| TTex HoldenSettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
 George HugginsSettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
| FFred KennedySettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
| AAl KundeFiddler (uncredited) | Fiddler (uncredited) |
| AAnn KundeSettler (uncredited) | Settler (uncredited) |
 Frank McGrathPosse Member (uncredited) | Posse Member (uncredited) |
