Young Natty is an aspiring writer who works at a video store. As he writes in his time between customers, his hero/nemesis comes to life before him living out the stories that he has created.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Joe EgenderNatty | Natty |
 Patrick John FluegerDick (credited as Patrick Flueger) | Dick (credited as Patrick Flueger) |
 Michele MorrowAlice | Alice |
 Ted RaimiFrancis | Francis |
 Alexandra BarretoEmma (credited as Alex Barreto) | Emma (credited as Alex Barreto) |
 Dina MeyerMs. Motley | Ms. Motley |
 Gregory ItzinMr. Briggs | Mr. Briggs |
 Lin ShayeThe Lush | The Lush |
 Paul ZiesMonster | Monster |
 Randall ParkSoldier Somethingorother | Soldier Somethingorother |
 Jody CarlsonThe Tart (credited as Jody Carlson-Astrom) | The Tart (credited as Jody Carlson-Astrom) |
| TTimothy SheehanNot listed | Not listed |
| CChristopher ShomoNot listed | Not listed |
| CChuck HayesNot listed | Not listed |
| AArolyn BurnsNot listed | Not listed |
| NNatalie McMillanNot listed | Not listed |
| SShaun PilkingtonNot listed | Not listed |
| SSeth DonaldNot listed | Not listed |
| JJonathan HayNot listed | Not listed |
| DDrew AdamsNot listed | Not listed |