One Night Only: Rivals 2 was a professional wrestling pay-per-view (PPV) event produced by Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (TNA), where TNA held a series of matches featuring various TNA wrestlers renewing their heated feuds in TNA History. The show was taped in parts on January 5– 7, 2016, at the Sands Bethlehem Event Center in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania and was shown on PPV on February 5, 2016.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Matt Hardy"Broken" Matt Hardy | "Broken" Matt Hardy |
 Michael HutterEthan Carter III | Ethan Carter III |
 Andrew GallowayDrew Galloway | Drew Galloway |
 Shaun RickerEli Drake | Eli Drake |
 Ken AndersonMr. Anderson | Mr. Anderson |
 Thom LatimerBram | Bram |
 Franklin Roberto LashleyLashley | Lashley |
 Amanpreet SinghMahabali Shera | Mahabali Shera |
 Robert StraussRobbie E. | Robbie E. |
 Jessie GodderzJessie Godderz | Jessie Godderz |
 Stephanie BellJade | Jade |
 Martibel PayanoMarti Belle | Marti Belle |
 Jamie SzantyrVelvet Sky | Velvet Sky |
 Ashley LombergerMadison Rayne | Madison Rayne |
 Gail KimGail Kim (Archive Footage) | Gail Kim (Archive Footage) |
 Kia StevensAwesome Kong (Archive Footage) | Awesome Kong (Archive Footage) |
 Tigre UnoTigre Uno | Tigre Uno |
 James CurtinRockstar Spud | Rockstar Spud |
 Jeremy FritzEric Young | Eric Young |
 Chris MelendezChris Melendez | Chris Melendez |
 Wesley David RichardsDavey Richards | Davey Richards |
 Eric MaherEddie Edwards | Eddie Edwards |
 Tanea BrooksRebel (Ringside) | Rebel (Ringside) |