A town in Arizona gave all their horses to General Custer, with the promise that they would get their horses back or be paid. The Mayor keeps it a secret about what happened to Custer, the horses, and the money. Carson uncovers the truth.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| NNathan DefrancisLee Carter | Lee Carter |
| BBryan KeeterMorton Bennett | Morton Bennett |
| MMichael B. MitchellVincent Vegas | Vincent Vegas |
| LLiza LucasElizabeth Carson | Elizabeth Carson |
| SScott HairstonJimmy | Jimmy |
 John MarrsHubbard Stapleton | Hubbard Stapleton |
 Blaize NaaszFreight worker | Freight worker |
| MMike DohertyTownsperson | Townsperson |
| CCara LeoniTownsperson | Townsperson |