A group of true-crime podcasters travel back to the scene of the Darien Cross cult killings to investigate what really happened a decade ago during the events of the first film.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| SStephanie WardTrixie | Trixie |
| HHillary Schmatolla-BrooksAngela | Angela |
| JJoe CappelliSheriff Baker | Sheriff Baker |
 Patricia c RodriguezAriella | Ariella |
| SShauna CheathamMorgan | Morgan |
| IIssaiah VergaraRon | Ron |
| KKira StarrSloane | Sloane |
 Adam HolleyJeremy | Jeremy |
| SShawn M. EsslerKyle | Kyle |
| BBela AjtaiDarien Cross | Darien Cross |
| JJames S. CacciatoreTheo | Theo |
 Michelle DiBernardoJen | Jen |
| PPatrick ReganWayne | Wayne |
| KKristina SantiagoCamper Girl 3 | Camper Girl 3 |
 Jamie MorganCamper Girl 2 | Camper Girl 2 |
| CChase DunsmoorOrderly #2 | Orderly #2 |
| DDavid GilmoreSheriff Deputy | Sheriff Deputy |
| RRyan LoMedicoCamper Guy 2 | Camper Guy 2 |