This heartbreaking story follows young newly weds and parents Sara and Matthew Atkins, who are treated by Cecilia Pederson four weeks before she calls John Kramer. What are the tragic, life changing effects on those Cecilia Pederson scams?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Synnøve Macody LundCecilia Pederson (archive footage) | Cecilia Pederson (archive footage) |
 Renata VacaGabriela (archive footage) | Gabriela (archive footage) |
| PPaulette HernándezValentina (archive footage) | Valentina (archive footage) |
 Joshua OkamotoDiego (archive footage) | Diego (archive footage) |
 Octavio Hinojosa MartínezMateo (archive footage) | Mateo (archive footage) |
 Donagh GordonFinn Pederson (archive footage) | Finn Pederson (archive footage) |
| NNick AucoinPolice Commissioner | Police Commissioner |
| MMiya HigashiyamaSara Atkins | Sara Atkins |
 A WheelerCoroner / Dr. Young | Coroner / Dr. Young |
| RRyan BradleyReporter Jackson | Reporter Jackson |
 Lily SpringerAlexandra Smith | Alexandra Smith |
| LLoki DeWittReporter Davis | Reporter Davis |
| SSalem MazurReporter Taylor | Reporter Taylor |
| BBlakeDr. Andrews | Dr. Andrews |
| JJillian FrickeReporter Richardson | Reporter Richardson |
| NNicholas StevensMatthew Atkins | Matthew Atkins |