 Paul MuniOrin Nordholm Jr. | Orin Nordholm Jr. |
 Aline MacMahonAnna Nordholm | Anna Nordholm |
 Mary AstorVirginia Claffin Nordholm | Virginia Claffin Nordholm |
 Donald CookRichard Nordholm | Richard Nordholm |
 Jean MuirSelma Peterson / Granddaughter Selma | Selma Peterson / Granddaughter Selma |
 Guy KibbeeJames Claffin | James Claffin |
 Mickey RooneyOtto Peterson as a Child | Otto Peterson as a Child |
 Patricia EllisNatalie Clifton Nordholm | Natalie Clifton Nordholm |
 Theodore NewtonPaul Nordholm | Paul Nordholm |
 Margaret LindsayJennifer Nordholm | Jennifer Nordholm |
 Gordon WestcottJohn Nordholm | John Nordholm |
 Henry O'NeillOrin Nordholm Sr. | Orin Nordholm Sr. |
 William JanneyOrin Nordholm III | Orin Nordholm III |
 Douglass DumbrilleBuffalo Bill Cody | Buffalo Bill Cody |
 Alan MowbraySir Philip Ivor | Sir Philip Ivor |
 Sidney TolerMr. Hodgens | Mr. Hodgens |
 Anna Q. NilssonMrs. Peterson | Mrs. Peterson |
 Arthur HohlMr. Patten | Mr. Patten |
 Alan DinehartOgden Jarrett | Ogden Jarrett |
 Oscar ApfelMr. Morley, a Banker | Mr. Morley, a Banker |
 Wallis ClarkMr. Freddie McCord, a Clerk | Mr. Freddie McCord, a Clerk |
 Clay ClementLt. Col. George Armstrong Custer | Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer |
 William BurressMr. Krauss, a Banker | Mr. Krauss, a Banker |
 Marjorie GatesonMrs. Clinton | Mrs. Clinton |
 James BushOrin III's Roommate (uncredited) | Orin III's Roommate (uncredited) |
 George ChandlerPiano Player (uncredited) | Piano Player (uncredited) |
 Philip FavershamNordholm's Clerk (uncredited) | Nordholm's Clerk (uncredited) |
 John ElliottA Banker (uncredited) | A Banker (uncredited) |
 Mary GordonLady at Party (uncredited) | Lady at Party (uncredited) |
| EEddie GrahamSteamship Clerk (uncredited) | Steamship Clerk (uncredited) |
