Poor health and alcoholism force Grover Cleveland Alexander out of baseball, but through his wife's faithful efforts, he gets a chance for a comeback and redemption.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Doris DayAimee Alexander | Aimee Alexander |
 Ronald ReaganGrover Cleveland Alexander | Grover Cleveland Alexander |
 Frank LovejoyRogers Hornsby | Rogers Hornsby |
 Eve MillerMargaret Killefer | Margaret Killefer |
 James MillicanBill Killefer | Bill Killefer |
 Russ TamblynWillie Alexander | Willie Alexander |
 Gordon JonesGeorge Glasheen | George Glasheen |
 Hugh SandersJoe McCarthy | Joe McCarthy |
 Frank FergusonSam Arrants | Sam Arrants |
 Dorothy AdamsMa Alexander | Ma Alexander |
| BBob LemonJesse 'Pop' Haines | Jesse 'Pop' Haines |
| JJerry PriddyBallplayer | Ballplayer |
| PPeanuts LoweryBallplayer | Ballplayer |
| GGeorge MetkovichBallplayer | Ballplayer |
| IIrving NorenBallplayer | Ballplayer |
| HHank SauerBallplayer | Ballplayer |
| AAl ZarillaBallplayer | Ballplayer |
| GGene MauchBallplayer | Ballplayer |
 Walter BaldwinPa Alexander (uncredited) | Pa Alexander (uncredited) |
| JJack CarrAngry Fan (uncredited) | Angry Fan (uncredited) |