The neighbors of a frontier family turn on them when it is suspected that their beloved adopted daughter was stolen from the Kiowa tribe.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Burt LancasterBen Zachary | Ben Zachary |
 Audrey HepburnRachel Zachary | Rachel Zachary |
 Audie MurphyCash Zachary | Cash Zachary |
 John SaxonJohnny Portugal | Johnny Portugal |
 Charles BickfordZeb Rawlins | Zeb Rawlins |
 Lillian GishMattilda Zachary | Mattilda Zachary |
 Albert SalmiCharlie Rawlins | Charlie Rawlins |
 Joseph WisemanAbe Kelsey | Abe Kelsey |
 June WalkerHagar Rawlins | Hagar Rawlins |
 Kipp HamiltonGeorgia Rawlins | Georgia Rawlins |
| AArnold MerrittJude Rawlins | Jude Rawlins |
 Doug McClureAndy Zachary | Andy Zachary |
 Carlos RivasLost Bird | Lost Bird |