A spoiled brat sends a very long list to Santa Claus who misdelivers the gifts to a town with the same name as the boy, who learns it's better to give than receive.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Dick Van DykeNarrator/ Old Jeremy Creek (voice) | Narrator/ Old Jeremy Creek (voice) |
 Miko HughesYoung Jeremy Creek (voice) | Young Jeremy Creek (voice) |
 Ashley JohnsonGranddaughter (voice) | Granddaughter (voice) |
| MMelinda PetersonMrs. Creek (voice) | Mrs. Creek (voice) |
 Phil ProctorMr. Creek (voice) | Mr. Creek (voice) |
 Hal SmithSanta Claus (voice) | Santa Claus (voice) |
| MMelinda PetersonMrs. Creek | Mrs. Creek |
| Phil ProctorMr. Creek | Mr. Creek |
 Neil RossPout the Elf | Pout the Elf |
 B.J. WardNeighbor | Neighbor |
 Paul WilliamsPomp the Elf | Pomp the Elf |