Tethered by a frightening conclusion, Maya and the Strangers are locked on an unavoidable, unforgiving collision course — a showdown that proves they’re far from strangers now.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Madelaine PetschMaya | Maya |
 Richard BrakeSheriff Rotter | Sheriff Rotter |
 Ema HorvathShelly / Pinup | Shelly / Pinup |
 Gabriel BassoGregory / Scarecrow | Gregory / Scarecrow |
 Pedro LeandroDeputy Walters | Deputy Walters |
 Rachel ShentonDebbie | Debbie |
 George YoungHoward | Howard |
 Kyle BreitkopfTeenage Gregory / Scarecrow | Teenage Gregory / Scarecrow |
 Finn CofellTeenage Pinup | Teenage Pinup |
 Stevee DaviesDougie | Dougie |
 Hannah GalwayClaire | Claire |
 Sara FreedlandAnnie | Annie |
 Dani KlupschCarrie | Carrie |
 Ella BruccoleriJasmine | Jasmine |
 Krystal EllsworthDollface | Dollface |
 Janis AhernCarol | Carol |
 Pablo SandstromNeil | Neil |
 Stephanie AubertinTeenage Dollface | Teenage Dollface |
| NNicholas ChaifSleazy Guy | Sleazy Guy |
 Jake CogmanYoung Scarecrow | Young Scarecrow |
| LLeo PetrusJudge | Judge |
| CCanaan DavisonTeenage Lumberjack | Teenage Lumberjack |
 Nola WallaceYoung Pinup | Young Pinup |
 Ben CartwrightRudy | Rudy |
 Joel LabelleMan | Man |
| EEric HathernRadio Preacher (voice) | Radio Preacher (voice) |